So many times when I’ve worked with staff at schools the question is raised, which is better, Edmodo or Moodle? First of all, they are two different things entirely when you really know what they are. Is it stated on the Edmodo website that Edmodo is a K-12 social learning network “dedicated to connecting all learners with the people and resources they need to reach their full potential” (Edmodo, 2014). However, Moodle is stated as being “a learning platform designed to provide educators, administrators and learners with a single robust, secure and integrated system to create personalised learning environments“, as well as this, there is a philosophy behind the development of Moodle that states that “the design and development of Moodle is guided by a “social constructionist pedagogy” (Moodle, 2012). To me, it is pretty obvious that each of these two products serves distinctly different purposes.
There have been numerous teachers in places I have worked who claim Edmodo to be the best digital learning tool for all teaching and learning activities. I decided to give it a good go with students a year ago and see for myself how it worked as a learning tool. It worked well in some instances, and I had about 250 students using it for a range of activities and discussions. I awarded badges to students based on things they were doing and interacted with them as they completed activities and wrote their reflections etc as replies to posts. However, after a while, the issues became this: students forgot passwords and would create new accounts instead of contacting me to find out their password or seek help; students couldn’t find the assigned activities in the feed of comments and activities; and, students focused too much on the social and not enough on completing work and learning. These are things I found fundamentally disadvantageous to quality teaching and learning.
Moodle on the other hand facilitates teaching and learning that is both synchronous and asynchronous; collaborative and independent; and, passive as well as interactive. Courses in Moodle can be designed to facilitate learning that is based on a linear pathway of content and activities or it can be designed to be completely individualised based on student groups, or some other student-based variable. For example, completing a lesson activity, students may answer questions in different ways that take them in different directions, depending on the lesson setup. I could honestly go on about the things I believe set Moodle apart from other systems as a learning management system but basically it is because Moodle facilitates learning customisation, creativity, collaboration and personalisation.
Check out some of these other blog posts that discuss the Edmodo vs Moodle issues:
- Moodle vs Edmodo – The DigiTeacher
- Edmodo vs Schoology vs Moodle vs Weebly vs Google Sites (Part 2) – Ms Claudia Lee
- Edmodo and Moodle | Quick Review – Roodhouse Tech Blog
Ultimately, Moodle is a learning management system and Edmodo is not, it is simply a social learning environment that connects people with the potential to learn.